Essentially all tint is illegal unless it comes from factory aka you drive what is classified as a SUBURBAN vehicle (Minivans, SUVs, CUVs, some wagons etc.).
Remember factory never tints the passenger and driver window or windshield.
If you have tint you are technically illegal (half of NYC rides around with tint though, myself included). It depends on the cop and who has time. If they ever pull you over, don't be surprised if he slaps on the extra fine for the tint. If you're egregious with like blacked out windows then power to you, you're more likely to be a target.
I find that you are much more likely to get pulled over in the 5 boroughs than upstate or on Long Island... or at least in my experiences.
I used to be in Manhattan/Brooklyn/Staten Island a lot and I got a few tickets for it there. I literally got pulled over just for the tint (20% on my previous car). I've gotten one tint ticket on Long Island but I was already pulled over for something else...
I recently just got 35% on my GTI so we'll see how it goes. 35 isn't as bad as 20 though, I don't expect to be pulled over for it on the island.
I find that you are much more likely to get pulled over in the 5 boroughs than upstate or on Long Island... or at least in my experiences.
I used to be in Manhattan/Brooklyn/Staten Island a lot and I got a few tickets for it there. I literally got pulled over just for the tint (20% on my previous car). I've gotten one tint ticket on Long Island but I was already pulled over for something else...
I recently just got 35% on my GTI so we'll see how it goes. 35 isn't as bad as 20 though, I don't expect to be pulled over for it on the island.