GOLFMK8
GOLFMK7
GOLFMK6
GOLFMKV

APR DTR6054 Direct Turbocharger Replacement System

starsmith

Go Kart Champion
Location
Shakytown, CA
Car(s)
2019 Urano Grey GTI
OK so since yall speculated on where I'm getting these numbers, and I think this is valuable to discussions about when a given amount of power is useful or not, here is a detailed derivation of the absolute maximum power that a FWD car can put down at a given speed. This makes some simplifying assumptions, but is valid at the low (~45mph) speeds we have been discussing, where both drag and downforce are too weak to be important in any road car.

Assume the power of the car is P. Power is the rate at which mechanical work is done, and work is the product of force and distance. Since velocity is the rate at which distance increases, the rate at which work is done is the product of force and velocity, F * v, so P = F v and hence

F = P / v (Eq 1)

Assume now your car is at the absolute limit of its front wheel grip - the force of friction is F = μ F_N, where μ is the coefficient of friction and F_N is the force with which the tire is pushing against the surface. In this case, we assume F_N is equal to the fraction of the vehicle's weight on the front wheels, around f = 60% of the weight for a GTI. So the forward thrust provided at the wheels is

F = μ f m g (Eq 2)

Here m is the mass of the car and g is the acceleration due to gravity, 9.8 m/s^2. μ will be ~1.2-1.3 for the absolute best road tire in existence on the absolute nicest unprepped track surface in existence, whereas you can get more like ~2 in drag conditions. We are neglecting weight transfer here because we want a best-case scenario - in practice the car will lift off its front wheels, reducing f. This is what suspension setup can help with somewhat.

OK now equate F from Eqs. 1 and 2. We have

P / v = μ f m g

Solving for P, the maximum power you can put down is

P = μ v f m g

Plugging in μ=1.3, f=0.6, m=3300lb, g = 9.8m/s^2, and v = 45mph, we obtain a maximum power that can be put down of about 300hp. Remember, this is assuming 0 wheel hop, 0 weight transfer, and absolute top-shelf sticky meaty rubber on clean asphalt, so in practice it will be less. That's why tuned GTIs like to spin if you mash the throttle from a 40 roll in 3rd.
 
Last edited:

SnailPower

Autocross Newbie
Location
North NJ
Car(s)
2017 GTI MT, PP, LP
OK so since yall speculated on where I'm getting these numbers, and I think this is valuable to discussions about when a given amount of power is useful or not, here is a detailed derivation of the absolute maximum power that a FWD car can put down at a given speed. This makes some simplifying assumptions, but is valid at the low (~45mph) speeds we have been discussing, where both drag and downforce are too weak to be important in any road car.

Assume the power of the car is P. Power is the rate at which mechanical work is done, and work is the product of force and distance. Since velocity is the rate at which distance increases, the rate at which work is done is the product of force and velocity, F * v, so P = F v and hence

F = P / v (Eq 1)

Assume now your car is at the absolute limit of its front wheel grip - the force of friction is F = μ F_N, where μ is the coefficient of friction and F_N is the force with which the tire is pushing against the surface. In this case, we assume F_N is equal to the fraction of the vehicle's weight on the front wheels, around f = 60% of the weight for a GTI. So the forward thrust provided at the wheels is

F = μ f m g (Eq 2)

Here m is the mass of the car and g is the acceleration due to gravity, 9.8 m/s^2. μ will be ~1.2-1.3 for the absolute best road tire in existence on the absolute nicest unprepped track surface in existence, whereas you can get more like ~2 in drag conditions. We are neglecting weight transfer here because we want a best-case scenario - in practice the car will lift off its front wheels, reducing f.

OK now equate F from Eqs. 1 and 2. We have

P / v = μ f m g

Solving for P, the maximum power you can put down is

P = μ v f m g. Plugging in μ=1.3, f=0.6, m=3300lb, g = 9.8m/s^2, and v = 45mph, we obtain a maximum power that can be put down of about 300hp. Remember, this is assuming 0 weight transfer and absolute top-shelf sticky meaty rubber on clean asphalt, so in practice it will be less.
vg7fd.jpg
 

jawndropper

Drag Racing Champion
Location
Tysons, VA
Car(s)
2017 GTI Sport
OK so since yall speculated on where I'm getting these numbers, and I think this is valuable to discussions about when a given amount of power is useful or not, here is a detailed derivation of the absolute maximum power that a FWD car can put down at a given speed. This makes some simplifying assumptions, but is valid at the low (~45mph) speeds we have been discussing, where both drag and downforce are too weak to be important in any road car.

Assume the power of the car is P. Power is the rate at which mechanical work is done, and work is the product of force and distance. Since velocity is the rate at which distance increases, the rate at which work is done is the product of force and velocity, F * v, so P = F v and hence

F = P / v (Eq 1)

Assume now your car is at the absolute limit of its front wheel grip - the force of friction is F = μ F_N, where μ is the coefficient of friction and F_N is the force with which the tire is pushing against the surface. In this case, we assume F_N is equal to the fraction of the vehicle's weight on the front wheels, around f = 60% of the weight for a GTI. So the forward thrust provided at the wheels is

F = μ f m g (Eq 2)

Here m is the mass of the car and g is the acceleration due to gravity, 9.8 m/s^2. μ will be ~1.2-1.3 for the absolute best road tire in existence on the absolute nicest unprepped track surface in existence, whereas you can get more like ~2 in drag conditions. We are neglecting weight transfer here because we want a best-case scenario - in practice the car will lift off its front wheels, reducing f. This is what suspension setup can help with somewhat.

OK now equate F from Eqs. 1 and 2. We have

P / v = μ f m g

Solving for P, the maximum power you can put down is

P = μ v f m g

Plugging in μ=1.3, f=0.6, m=3300lb, g = 9.8m/s^2, and v = 45mph, we obtain a maximum power that can be put down of about 300hp. Remember, this is assuming 0 wheel hop, 0 weight transfer, and absolute top-shelf sticky meaty rubber on clean asphalt, so in practice it will be less. That's why tuned GTIs like to spin if you mash the throttle from a 40 roll in 3rd.
man-talking-to-wall.gif
 

jawndropper

Drag Racing Champion
Location
Tysons, VA
Car(s)
2017 GTI Sport
I just got off the phone with NGP and they were seriously concerned about running this tune with a downpipe.
 

starsmith

Go Kart Champion
Location
Shakytown, CA
Car(s)
2019 Urano Grey GTI
This makes sense if you assume that the car never actually goes faster than 45mph.
I acknowledged that other effects become important in the first paragraph, but only at significantly higher speeds or with crazy aero shit. They are not generally important at the speed where a typical car transitions from being traction-limited to power-limited (i.e. starts putting the power down), so the above expression is pretty reasonable.
 

jawndropper

Drag Racing Champion
Location
Tysons, VA
Car(s)
2017 GTI Sport
Didn’t they clearly define thier concerns? Or just say we are concerned.
They said it could run dangerously lean. They are going to reach out to APR and get back to me. Based on Arins responses in this thread about emissions, I dont expect any comment from APR other than “We designed and tested the kit with the stock downpipe”.
 
Last edited:

crxgator

Autocross Champion
Location
Raleigh, NC
Car(s)
All the MQBs
That was like a tripled double down. Settle down there Lebron AWD.
 

scrllock

Autocross Champion
Location
MI
I acknowledged that other effects become important in the first paragraph, but only at significantly higher speeds or with crazy aero shit. They are not generally important at the speed where a typical car transitions from being traction-limited to power-limited (i.e. starts putting the power down), so the above expression is pretty reasonable.
the point isn't the actual modeling (which yes, is much more complicated than a simple P = μ v f m g), it's that even if you assume the model is true, your usable "power" would increase linearly anyway. In the real world, a little spin at 45 isn't that bad, as it will just put more heat into the tire and give you a lot more grip (and usable power) by the time you hit 60.

I do agree that it must suck to be a FWD peasant though.
 
Top