Think I'm done getting insurance quotes now. I probably won't go the costco/connect route. They got a lot of bad reviews.
I think it'll be between all state and state farm. With similar coverages all state came in at $171 a month, and state farm at $164 a month.
I have a pretty long history with all state due to being on my parents policy with my first few cars. Apparently I never got taken off their policy when I got my golf R and got my own. I might lean to all state just because of that, and hoping that my history with them will help me if I ever need to rely on insurance.
They both me want to sign up for their app that watches your driving behaviors for additional savings, but I don't think it's a good idea. All state was telling me your policy can't increase because of the app and the worst that can happen is I only get a 1% discount. I might have to look into this more, but I'm mostly against it.