I had a really specific list of needs: Good fuel economy (~30mpg), regular fuel, simple drivetrain (no CVT, no sideways engine), covered cargo space for unexpected rain, able to carry four AX tires/wheels and four adults, AWD because snow, not awful to work on. I was ultimately left with the CX-5 being the only thing that made sense and didn't cost a fortune -- our loaded 2020 was 24.5k OTD, with under 15k miles on it. Base engine so it's not fast, but it's not as awful as some I've been in.
GTI is a fantastic DD, it does a little of everything well. 52" toolbox in my mk4 wagon is my personal point of pride, though I also used to stuff an adult-sized bicycle in the hatch of my mk4 Golf.