Well, it seems that politically talk will be allowed to continue in the "Off Topic / Misc" areas of an obscure car forum. I have a few personal take aways from this interesting roller coaster:
1. Political talk should remain relegated to the off topic areas.
2. Higher doses of common courtesy are needed, no matter the viewpoint.
3. Jay and the other moderators have a thankless job, similar to the project manager dilemma. The best outcome a good PM can hope for is when all stakeholders are slightly annoyed with the PM.
I believe in open and free thought, despite it being a messy affair in practice. But there is a certain level of responsibility that should be coupled with free speech. It should not be used as a tool to be rude, slanderous or used as an excuse to ignore natural consequences to bad behavior. We can all do better. Carry on my fellow car lovers!