I’ve had the exact same issue with my 2015 GTI. A month or two ago found my spare tire well filled with water. Used a Shop Vac and got all the water out, dried out the liner etc. , but didn’t have much time to look into it. A couple weeks ago noticed the back back seat was damp, so I lifted it up and squeezed the cushion from the bottom and it was absolutely drenched with water, and so was the spare tire well. (It had rained pretty hard and almost everyday for about a week-week and a half) I used the Shop Vac and sucked as much water out of the cushion as I could while squeezing it (wringing it out) and dried everything back up again, and kept everything out of the hatch. Did some research and came across this. Two days ago I vacuumed everything out and sprinkled a bit of baby powder in the whole area and then washed the car. Found water coming from the rear right Vent. Pocket behind vent filled with water, bottom vent flap out of the four was also wet, so I checked the other side and it was damp, but not like the right side. I dried everything up, cleaned everything up with isopropyl alcohol and was gonna seal the vents with RTV silicone or PRC sealant, and someone suggested “Flex Seal” from the infomercia’s. I watched the flex seal videos again on YouTube and decided to give it a shot... I got the liquid stuff which is decently thick (viscous) in black so I could see exactly where I was putting it. I used a small 3/4” paint brush and put that shit all around the edges of the vent, the bottom of the four vents, the bottom of the compartment behind the vent, the welds in the corner, and alone the rear aft wall at the bottom along to the other side, and did the left side as well, but not as much. I applied a second coat the next day (today), removed the tail lights and ran a small thin bead of silicone around the foam seal on each tail light and re-installed the tail lights, then replaced the broken POS drain line coming from the symbol on the hatch. Gonna let everything dry for a day or two, then go wash the car again and see if I can find water anywhere. If it’s not any of those things then I’ll be at a loss for what it could be. I have a question : Does anybody know if I should drill a couple holes in the floor part of the hatch, or beneath those vents, or anywhere like that? I sealed over all of those useless “drains or drain plugs” that apparently didn’t work in the first place.