Been a long time since I've been in this thread, but here's my update on this not yet finished project. The short version is the dealer, and whoever they are calling at VWoA, do not appear to know much about coding/adaptations... long version is below if you're looking for some light reading, haha.
1) I ordered a BCM from the dealer, the one called out in ETKA as the replacement for my BCM... had 5Q0-937-087Q and replaced with 5Q0-937-087S which ETKA says is the replacement for -Q and -R BCM's. I checked this BCM and it has all the pins my old one was missing, perfect!
2) Was quoted 3 hours by the dealer to replace and program new BCM... work to be done at the same visit as my 30k service
3) The day before dropping the car off... fresh auto-scan and adaptation maps of every module in the car, including BCM (which has no faults)
- Note: I have Mk7.5 tail lights with JBale harness so a few of my adaptations for rear tail lights have been changed... so I expect those errors when I get the car back, no big deal
4) Got the car back, noted that my key fobs did not work (car will start of course since BCM isn't tied to immobilizer)
- Quick VCDS scan shows a single BCM fault, "Remote Control - Missing Calibration/Basic Setting)... makes sense, and means they didn't scan for faults after replacing the BCM
5) Went home, took adaptation map, then pulled out the coding worksheet for my tails... start of the problems
- when I first coded the tails I wrote the original values beside each changed value on the coding sheet... my new BCM "original values" are different... why?
- so before making any changes I decide to turn on my headlights... dashboard gives me errors for tails (expected) but also for front headlights and parking lights (these are new)
6) So I pull up my "new original" ad-map and my "old original" ad-map in WinMerge and notice hundreds of differences
- weird ones like rear windshield tear drop wipe not active but also my front light channels now match the coding of cars with xenons, rear bulb types are all LED, and many more
7) Car goes back to the dealer, tell them I need key fobs paired and adaptation maps coded
8) Pick up car a day or two later, dealer says everything is good except some lighting faults... okay
9) I drive to an empty parking space... both key fobs now lock/unlock... take an adaptation map and nothing has changed
- dealer is closing, I want to leave car there but they want me to take it home, which means I have to bring it back, again
10) Took the car back this morning, a different tech was supposed to work the car, whom I spoke with about my specific problem, the adaption maps
11) Dealer calls and says they called VW (I assume VWoA) for assistance and were told they cannot change coding but the tech that was working my car (and made the call I assume) has gone home
- they tell me I can come get the car but I opt to leave it there... I work 2 miles from home, I'd rather walk to/from work for a week than make all these dealer trips
12) Dealer says they have documentation from VW to show me in the morning stating they aren't supposed to change coding, uggghhh
I can only assume this paperwork is referring to long coding. That makes perfect sense; and I don't want the dealer to change long coding anyway (the long coding actually matches on all my scans). I cannot (yet) get them to understand that adaptation maps are not the same as long coding, and that adaptation maps should be "coded" by them, based on my car's factory installed equipment. As it stands, it appears my new highline BCM is coded for a higher trim level vehicle (a car that would have come with this BCM, one with the lighting package at least).
I have to think their guided BCM replacement should ask for my VIN at some point, and use that to perform parameterization and adaptation mapping. If not, then how could the dealer actually replace a failed BCM? Parts cannot find my original BCM (5Q0-937-087Q) in their system meaning they would have to replace it with a -S BCM if I had an actual failure, which also tracks with I've read about VW only keeping the highline version of a given module in stock.
Furthermore, if they had actually gone through the complete BCM replacement process I suspect it would have told them to pair the key fobs. And even if the guided function didn't tell them that, a fault scan would have revealed the Remote Control fault in the module. Then again, this is probably my fault for going back to them... they did the coding for my AID and did not complete it fully, failing to input my car's mileage. My AID odometer reads ~6,000 miles, car has over 30k on it.
Part of me says cut my "losses" and set all my adaptation maps manually, which will take hours. Of course, I don't know what most of the channels mean as they're in German. I don't like changing things when I don't know what they are... but would you guys agree that it should be safe to match all the channels on my new BCM to what my car came with out of the factory? I would think it's safe, but right now any damage caused by incorrect adaptation mapping is the dealer's responsibility. Once I start messing with things that responsibility becomes mine.