Well I think the end result was great! However I did screw up the timing.
I probably could have let it cook unrapped for a little longer, or maybe just never wrapped it at all.
I pulled it at about 4.5 hrs when the temp was about 165. This was also around 1pm.
I thought I was going to have up to another 4 hours but it ended up finishing in Just 2.
Pulled it off around 3 and then wrapped it up in a towel and stuck it in a cooler till about 5:30.
The bone slid right out and I was able to just use my hands to shred it up.
So based on that, and the fact that it tasted good, I’d call it a success!
Before the grill:
And after:
Again this was a smaller one at 5.5lbs and I’m assuming that’s why it ended up not needing to cook for as long as I anticipated. It ended up just needing a little over 6 hours.
I also thought the outside was going to get a little crispier. When I hear the term “bark” that makes me think that there will be a crispy layer, but this was not the case.